Mild-moderate equine asthma: A scoping review of evidence supporting the consensus definition.

Kinnison T and McGilvray TA and Couëtil LL and Smith KC and Wylie CE and Bacigalupo SA and Gomez-Grau E and Cardwell JM

Veterinary journal (London, England : 1997) (2022) 286: 105865

DOI: 10.1016/j.tvjl.2022.105865

Abstract

Current consensus defines mild-moderate equine asthma (mEA; previously inflammatory airway disease) by a hierarchy of indicators of lung pathology: cough, poor performance, increased tracheobronchial mucus, inflammatory bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) cytology and pulmonary dysfunction. Exclusion criteria include fever, systemic disease, or increased resting respiratory effort. The aim of this review was to inform future research by identifying gaps, strengths and weaknesses in the current body of evidence supporting this consensus-proposed definition. Objectives were to critique evidence supporting the inclusion of each diagnostic indicator in the case definition, by summarising and evaluating evidence for its association with higher-level indicators of lung inflammation. Searches of three databases identified 2275 articles relating to mEA or its diagnostic indicators, from which 298 full-text articles were screened and 45 reviewed in full. Studies (n = 44) had been performed worldwide in clinics, hospitals, racetracks, yards or research herds, in 6092 horses. Studies were predominantly opportunistic observational (n = 13/44: 29.5%) or cross-sectional (n = 11/44; 25%). The median number of horses per study was 74. Where breed and use were reported most were Thoroughbreds (58.2%; 2730/4688) and racehorses (72.8%; n = 3960/5439). Domains rated as high risk of bias in almost 50% of articles were ’study power’ and ’masking’. Heterogeneity in clinical and laboratory measures precluded meta-analysis. Evidence was more consistent for certain pairwise relationships (e.g., between cough and tracheobronchial mucus) than others (e.g., BAL cytology and lung function). Findings highlight the need for increased standardisation of diagnostic methods and reporting to facilitate future systematic review and meta-analysis.

Citation

Kinnison T, McGilvray TA, Couëtil LL, Smith KC, Wylie CE, Bacigalupo SA, Gomez-Grau E, & Cardwell JM. (2022). Mild-moderate equine asthma: A scoping review of evidence supporting the consensus definition. Veterinary Journal (London, England : 1997), 286, 105865. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tvjl.2022.105865 Animals, Cross-Sectional Studies, Horses, Consensus, Bronchoalveolar Lavage Fluid, Asthma, *Asthma/diagnosis/veterinary, *Horse Diseases/diagnosis, Cough/etiology/veterinary

Keywords

• Animals
• Cross-Sectional Studies
• Horses
• Consensus
• Bronchoalveolar Lavage Fluid
• Asthma
• *Asthma/diagnosis/veterinary
• *Horse Diseases/diagnosis
• Cough/etiology/veterinary