Environmental enrichment increases aquatic animal welfare: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Zhang ZongHang and Gao LiJia and Zhang XiuMei

Reviews in Aquaculture (2022) 14: 1120–1135

DOI: 10.1111/raq.12641

Abstract

With the rapid development of aquaculture and the gradual decrease in fishery resources, aquatic animal welfare (AAW) has received increasing attention from animal protection organisations, government departments, biologists, fish culturists and consumers. Although environmental enrichment (EE) can potentially benefit AAW, the relevant results are sharply mixed, and the drivers for these discrepancies are largely unclear. In this study, we conducted a series of meta-analyses to overcome this knowledge gap. We firstly compiled a full data set, consisting of 1171 effect sizes from 147 studies across 82 species and then performed a multilevel mixed-effects model to evaluate the overall effect size and conduct the subsequent meta-regression analyses. Overall, our results showed that aquatic animals from a physically enriched environment had significantly improved AAW compared with their counterparts from barren environments. For moderators, specific welfare traits, animal taxa, animal stages, enrichment types and enrichment colours showed strong positive EE effects on AAW. Subsequently, we constructed a fish data set and reran the meta-analysis, yielding results substantially similar to those obtained using the full data set. Finally, we performed a multi-model inference to identify the importance ranking of potential moderators. Results showed that enrichment type, animal taxon and welfare category are the best moderators of the direction and magnitude of EE effects on AAW. These results provide insights into the possible drivers of EE effects on aquatic animals with important implications for aquaculture, fisheries, conservation, research and aquarium, providing evidence-based guidance for future animal welfare theories and practices.

Citation

Zhang ZongHang, Gao LiJia, & Zhang XiuMei. (2022). Environmental enrichment increases aquatic animal welfare: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Reviews in Aquaculture, 14(3), 1120–1135. https://doi.org/10.1111/raq.12641 Animals, meta-analysis, systematic reviews, aquatic animals, aquatic organisms, animal welfare, aquaculture, Animal Shells, fisheries

Keywords

• Animals
• meta-analysis
• systematic reviews
• aquatic animals
• aquatic organisms
• animal welfare
• aquaculture
• Animal Shells
• fisheries